Game Design Laws: Progress
Laws about the shape of the whole game: its length, its completion and the progress the player makes. The index and the way a game uses them are in Game Design Laws.
Start And End
The game has a start and an end. That also counts for prestige and new game plus.
As Long As It Is Interesting
The game is as long as it is interesting, not the other way around.
- No level, scene or story beat has a target length. Everything is there as it should be
- Nothing is stretched to fill a playtime, and nothing is cut to meet one
- A fast player goes fast
- The game ends while the player still wants more
Doable 100%
Completing the game 100% is reasonably doable. No orthogonal gameplay, like a parkour section in an automation game, that demands a different skill for completion. Pride in 100% comes from playing the entire game and doing all the side quests. A player grinding, bored, because of one missing side quest means the side challenges were designed wrong.
No Try Hard
Beating the game normally never requires playing try hard. The game supports every type of player, the completionist and the casual alike, by staying flexible and never forcing a play style. Optimizing is there for the player who wants it.
Earned Progress
The player feels the progress made, so the gap between where the player starts and ends is as big as it can be: the player starts with as little as possible and earns the rest. Nothing that can be earned is handed over. What comes for free is worth nothing. A free first step that starts a climb is no gift but the climb's first rung.
- Quality of life is earned too. A task is done by hand first and automated later, so losing friction is progress.
- Upgrades come in small, regular steps that are felt in play.
- Relevant for an economy: every step up brings a new risk beside the new unlock.
Lasting Impact
What the player does and decides has a lasting effect on the game's progress.
Emergent Gameplay
Systems whose mere existence opens possibilities for the player, play styles among them, rather than features that each do one thing.
Know What Is Coming
The player always knows what is coming in the short future: the next upgrade, the next unlock, the distance to the next goal, and when it is the end. There is always something coming, so the next upgrade or level is always looming. The world still keeps its secrets (Fair Surprise).