Game Design Laws: Experience
Laws about what the player lives through from moment to moment. The index and the way a game uses them are in Game Design Laws.
Never Wait
The player never has to wait, unless it is technically impossible to continue right away. When waiting is unavoidable, entertain the player.
Always Something To Do
The player always has something to do. Short term, the pull to expand and explore. Long term, a dot on the horizon. When closing in on it, the outline of the next dot is already visible. The ultimate goal is not revealed too soon, but is visible from early mid-game. Nothing new to pursue for a moment is not nothing to do: there is the state to check and the next choice to think about, such as the balance when there is nothing to buy yet. Leave space for thinking, just not too much when the player already knows what to do. The better the player plays, the less time there is to think.
Exploration Is Rewarded
A player who looks around, opens something or goes somewhere unasked always finds something there: a thing to build, a clue, a secret. Curiosity pays, so the explorer keeps exploring.
Full Control
The player feels in full control. Nothing is decided and nothing happens without the player taking action. A surprise of the world answers the player (Fair Surprise).
Respect
The player feels respected. No dumb tutorials. Feeling the need for a tutorial is a sign that something is not obvious.
Speedrun Ready
A returning player speedrunning the game has just as good an experience as a player starting for the first time.
Once Per Save
A story cutscene plays once per save, the first time its moment comes. Every later run of that save goes past it without stopping. A replayed run or a prestige never replays it, and a new save plays it again. A progression minigame plays once per save too: a later run passes a won minigame at once, its outcome given.
AFK Safe
The player can always be away, planned, unplanned or urgent, without negative effects from the game state. This goes two ways: nothing dies, nothing is lost and no events are missed while away, and nothing progresses beyond what the player set running. No blocking pop-ups that stop the game until OK is clicked.
- What the player set running keeps running until the player pauses it: a factory produces, perhaps until its materials run out, and currency grows.
- Nothing upgrades on its own, and no raid or heavy debuff lands while the player is away.
Easy Pause
Pausing is always easy.
Soft Sound
The mix is soft. A repeated sound varies a bit in pitch and length. A layer belongs to its scene: it starts with the scene and stops when the scene leaves. Playtest feedback on sound asks for softer, lower and more varied, never for louder.
Fun First
Player experience is priority number one. The game is fun, and so is the main gameplay loop.
- A test of the design: a good game clips well. Plain footage of the game being played holds a viewer.
- Footage that does not hold up points at a change in the design, never at more steering.
- Nothing is designed for the clip. A good game produces those moments by itself.
Loop First
The core loop is fun in a greybox, before anything is built on it. Looks, content and story do not rescue a loop that is no fun bare. The law is also the gate of the Prototype phase (Game Phases: Concept).