Game Design Laws
Laws are short rules that hold unless there is a very good reason to break one. The generic set lives in the standards, in eight parts by theme, and this standard is its index. A game's own laws and overrides stand in the game's docs.
Why
Design builds on what is settled, and an agent decides the small things on its own.
The Set
Experience
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Experience.
- Never Wait - the player never waits unless continuing is technically impossible. Unavoidable waiting entertains
- Always Something To Do - a pull short term, a dot on the horizon long term
- Exploration Is Rewarded - looking around always finds something
- Full Control - nothing is decided or happens without the player
- Respect - no dumb tutorials
- Speedrun Ready - a returning speedrunner has as good an experience as a first-time player
- Once Per Save - a story cutscene and a progression minigame play once per save
- AFK Safe - away without negative effect. Nothing is lost, and only what the player set running keeps running
- Easy Pause - pausing is always easy
- Soft Sound - a soft mix, varied repeats, a layer per scene
- Fun First - player experience is priority one. A good game clips well
- Loop First - the core loop is fun in a greybox, before anything is built on it
Progress
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Progress.
- Start And End - the game has both, prestige and new game plus included
- As Long As It Is Interesting - no target length
- Doable 100% - no orthogonal skill demanded for completion
- No Try Hard - every play style is supported
- Earned Progress - start with as little as possible and earn the rest
- Lasting Impact - what the player decides lasts
- Emergent Gameplay - systems that open possibilities
- Know What Is Coming - the next step and the distance to the next goal are always visible
Quality
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Quality.
- Always Polished - what goes out is polished, and whatever gets made is good at what it does
- Every Mechanic Matters - everything added adds value, or it goes
UI
The full text is in Game Design Laws: UI.
- Communicate State - what reacts, what is disabled and what changed shows it
- Alive App, Static Actions - something always moves, actions are instant
- No Hard Edges - rounded corners everywhere
- Glow In Contrast - a glow contrasts the text it wraps
- No Layout Shifts - controls never move while the player acts
- Same Trigger Both Ways - what opens an interaction closes it
- Say What Is Wrong - a warning carries its reason
- Mouse First - a PC game plays best on a mouse
Story
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Story.
- Show, Don't Tell - the player experiences it. Words short and never too spot on
- Worth Reading - for dialog: a missed line stays missed
- Dialog Gives Context - dialog accompanies the screen as narrative and gives context, never instructions
- Make Yourself - for a player character: the player can represent themselves
Guidance
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Guidance.
- No Yellow Paint - no steering that does the player's thinking. A hint is a context clue
- Answer The Player's Next Question - every word and number is weighed by what it means to the player
- Adopt, Repeat, Confirm (ARC) - a five step pattern for every new thing: awareness, trigger, adopt, repeat, confirm
World
The full text is in Game Design Laws: World.
- Fair Surprise - the world has rules the player finds by playing. A surprise answers the player, warns once and is readable after
- The World Reacts - an action leaves a trace that can be seen
- Friction In The World - friction is something the player does there, never a menu or a wait
Own Style
The full text is in Game Design Laws: Own Style.
- No Asset Flips - every asset is the game's own
- Blueprint First - things of one kind come from one blueprint
- Shown Together - everything of one kind is shown in one place
- Generate, Never Reuse - generate an asset, never reuse a pack
- Unique Where It Counts - unique in what makes the game, best practice for the rest
How To Apply
- The player is a human who walks the dog, answers the door, goes to sleep and continues the next day. Laws about that human, such as Easy Pause, Never Wait and AFK Safe, translate into any genre. Only their concrete shape changes.
- A game's laws doc has three parts: the generic laws it adopts, the ones it leaves out with a reason, and its own laws and overrides in full.
- An adopted or left-out law is named by its name in this set, never copied.
- A law for one kind of game says so in its name or in a
Relevant for:line, and is adopted or left out by it. - An exception is a paragraph under the law in the game's overrides, naming the feature and the reason, added only when the director affirms it.
- Check a new feature against the laws before its spec. A conflict is surfaced, never averaged.
- Feature docs link the law they lean on instead of repeating it.
- A new law goes in the game's docs, in the director's wording. One that holds for every game is filed with coentrify, its game specifics stripped (File A Change With Coentrify).