Game Design Laws: Guidance
Laws about what the game hints and teaches. The index and the way a game uses them are in Game Design Laws.
No Yellow Paint
Yellow paint is steering applied too much, the exemplary case being the painted ledge: an arrow, a hint, a helper or a quest log that does the player's thinking. Steering that is needed is not yellow paint. Where it seems needed, the design gets another look first. One thing on screen with a clear hover and interactable state needs no word to click it. Rich context clues drive the narration without deciding or thinking for the player. Two questions test it at any moment: what am I looking at, and what am I expected to do here.
- A hint is a context clue: it encloses what is already on screen in a narrative and gives it meaning, ambiguous and indirect, innocent without the context. It never motivates.
- Lines that cheer the player on, almost through, keep going, nearly there, do the opposite of a clue: they say nothing about the world and treat the player as someone who needs encouragement, which nobody does.
- Telling the player what to do belongs to a concept the player has not met before, and then once. A mechanic that has been introduced is never hinted again, and the line goes as soon as the concept has landed.
Answer The Player's Next Question
What the game shows is support for the player's decisions: it answers the question the player would ask at that moment, guiding their thoughts without steering them (Walk The User's Journey). So every word and number is weighed by what it means to the player there, never by what the system holds.
- A value means something only against a reference: 0 means nothing, Free says this is a purchase, things here cost something, and this one costs nothing.
- A purchase says what it gets the player, so they know where to look next.
- A tiered value shows where the player stands, where it goes and the difference, and makes plain whether a step adds to the last or multiplies it, and what it comes to in the game.
- Nothing is told in terms the player has not met yet: a currency is introduced as something to get, the wallet at 0, before a price is told in it. No buff on something that does not exist yet.
- It serves both ways of thinking: the explorer asking what can be done here, and the follower asking what the game wants done.
Adopt, Repeat, Confirm (ARC)
Every new thing is introduced in five steps, shaped to fit the thing, one new thing per link.
- Awareness: the feature is seen, no action yet
- Trigger: the conditions for the action are met
- Adopt: the player does it once
- Repeat: the player does it again
- Confirm: the third time confirms the action as a skill. It is a test that can be failed, an invitation, and the game just moves on
Confirm overlaps the next link's Awareness, so the pattern widens the horizon as it chains.